🇬🇧/🇩🇪 Instant Payment to DKB (and others) not working

SimonM

jorrit Any news on this topic? It is now not working for about 5 months...
And would you please check SCT Inst for comdirect COBADEHDXXX is also not working. They should be available since last week.

bunq -> Sparkasse (LBBW) : SCT Inst is still blocked
I there a chance that it will work again in the near future? Or will Sparkasse block bunq for ever...

Tam

Simon M Von Bunq zur SPK-WestHolstein funktioniert es, aber von der SPK zu Bunq nicht

SimonM

Tam 🇩🇪 That's what I wrote in the last update:
https://together.bunq.com/d/7692-instant-payment-to-dkb-and-others-not-working/332
I guess that SPK-WestHolstein is connected via HELABA
bunq -> Sparkasse (HELABA) : SCT Inst works
But good to know that it still works 👍 DKB is also connected via HELABA and works also.

Michael-ERL

Last information given by FinazInformatik directly from last Wednesday is, that they still block SCT-inst to bunq and that they don't have an update About when the blockade will be taken down again.

SCT-Inst from bunq -> Sparkasse Erlangen worked this week. The other way round took the usual workday.

SimonM

I was very surprised, when I was doing a payment to my old bank Sparkasse (via LBBW) the payment went as SCT Inst trough.

So, the Status, is to my knowledge, as following:

bunq -> DKB : SCT Inst works
bunq -> Sparkasse (HELABA) : SCT Inst works
bunq -> Sparkasse (LBBW) : SCT Inst is now working again 👍😬

Sparkasse (HELABA) -> bunq : SCT Inst blocked ?? - normal SEPA is possible
Sparkasse (LBBW) -> bunq : SCT Inst blocked ?? - normal SEPA is possible

bunq -> comdirect : should be possible since two weeks, maybe a DEV reads this...

Antworten

Kilian-Kilian-Kilian

Simon M, do you have an overview of which savings banks use HELABA for EBA clearing and which LBBW. I've been looking for a long time for an overview. The other Landesbanken do not seem to do that themselves, I just do not know their assignment.

Jorritt

Hi bunqers,

We're very happy to let you know that instant payments from Sparkasse to bunq are working once again ⚡️.

We’ve worked with Sparkasse to ensure that all bunqers and Sparkasse users are protected from fraud. One part of this means that new bunqers who sign up will need to use regular SCT transfers from Sparkasse accounts for their first month.

This is to better help minimise any losses that may occur if Sparkasse ever falls victim to a phishing attack in the future.

We decided that this was an acceptable compromise in order to proactively take the best precautions for these type of scenarios.

Thanks for your patience and we really appreciate your understanding in this adjustment.

Cheers,

Jorrit

JeroenE

jorrit Jullie blokkeren dan zelf de Instant Payments naar nieuwe gebruikers van bunq als ze van Sparkasse afkomstig zijn?

Bernd-Cyan-Penguin

jorrit Klingt gut. Ist damit auch das Problem vom Tisch, dass mehrere Sparkassen im Norden sich weigern Überweisungen an bunq auszuführen?

Roeshimi

jorrit That sounds good. How does Sparkasse know, if you are a new bunq user?

Bernd-Cyan-Penguin

jorrit Wie lange brauchen die Sparkassen um die Funktion bei allen Instituten wieder zu aktivieren? Ein Tag, eine Woche, nächster Software-Update-Termin?

Bernd-Cyan-Penguin

jorrit Gibt es einen Moderator für diesen Threat? wir haben uns bei jorrit bedankt für die Information und die damit verbundene Arbeit die nötig war um bis hierhin zu kommen. Es wurden verschiedene Fragen gestellt, die spontan auftraten:
+ Woher weiß die Sparkasse wer ein neuer bunqer ist?
+ Ab welchem Datum zählt der erste Monat?
+ Wer unterbindet die IP-Zahlungen bei new bunqers ( Sparkasse oder bunq)?
Es wäre nett hierzu Antworten zu erhalten. Falls noch weitere Fragen auftreten bitte anhängen, aber mich aus der Empfänger/Antwortbutton heraushalten (Auch ich muss mal schlafen).
Ich hoffe das der Übersetzer meinen Text nicht zu sehr zerstört.

SimonM

jorrit I had some problems with instant payment today. My payment to Sparkasse (connected via LBBW) was sent as normal SEPA, I am bunq customer since 2/2017 (longer then 30 days). Is it no longer working as intended? Or does the Sparkasse (LBBW) had some technical problems today?
At 25.6.19 / 27.06.19 / 28.06.19 / 3.7.19 and 16.7.19, I had no problems sending an Instant Payment to the same account at Sparkasse?
Anyone else has problems with IP to Sparkasse (LBBW)?

Simon-Lime-Badger

Jakob Vielen Dank für die Klarstellung!
Vermutlich meinst Du das
https://together.bunq.com/d/7692-instant-payment-to-dkb-and-others-not-working/349

jorrit We’ve worked with Sparkasse to ensure that all bunqers and Sparkasse users are protected from fraud. One part of this means that new bunqers who sign up will need to use regular SCT transfers from Sparkasse accounts for their first month.

Roeshimi

Bernd (DE - Hamburg)🇩🇪 It's working for my Sparkasse already. Just tested it

Heiko-Hartwig

Bernd (DE - Hamburg)🇩🇪 Landesbank Berlin bzw. Berliner Sparkasse hat ebenfalls soeben funktioniert. Kann die HASPA eigentlich mittlerweile SCT INST?

Bernd-Cyan-Penguin

Roeshimi Schön. Danke für die Info.

Bernd-Cyan-Penguin

Gerade getestet. Sparkasse Holstein führt weiterhin keine Überweisungen an bunq aus

Tam

Bernd (DE - Hamburg)🇩🇪 Bei SPK Westholstein hat es heute funktioniert.

Tobs

Finally works with LBBW 🙌🏼

Bernd-Cyan-Penguin

Heiko Hartwig HASPA: Nein!

Michael-ERL

SCT-Inst von Sparkasse Erlangen nach bunq hat gerade funktioniert 👍🏼

Robert-Silver-Turtle-4265395482

Sparkasse ostalbkreis Instant payment just worked for me. 👍

Heiko-Hartwig

Jetzt wäre DKB zu Bunq noch prima.

Bernd-Cyan-Penguin

Heiko Hartwig Die DKB bietet ausgehende IP-Zahlungen nicht an. Insofern ist das eine anders gelagerte Situation.